...However, I maintain that the majority of the Iranians who have not stopped protesting, risking their lives and those of their families, some being executed, some tortured, some disappeared, are NOT backers for the Reformist camp of Musavi and Co. I believe that within the very limited choice given - they opted to what they perceive to be the lesser evil - maybe not a door for radical change, but just a window of fresh air. I therefore agree to a great extent with both the analyses of Hamid Dabashi and the Iranian blogger Reza Fiyouzat when addressing the current Iranian unrest/revolt and the Left's stand on this matter. I also think that the Left in general is committing another huge mistake by not supporting the Iranian protests for change and reform. The idiotic conspiracy theories put forward by the leftists that the U.S, Saudi Arabia and even Israel are behind this unrest are ludicrous...
[56368] |
Uruknet on Alexa
:: Segnala Uruknet agli amici. Clicka qui.
:: Invite your friends to Uruknet. Click here.
:: Segnalaci un articolo :: Tell us of an article
:: If you find this site informative, please donate -
every donation helps us keep up with costs. Thanks.
:: If you find this site informative, please donate -
every donation helps us keep up with costs. Thanks.
|
|
"A Velvet Revolution "or Lesser Shades of Black ?
Layla Anwar, An Arab Woman Blues
July 26, 2009
Some speak of a "Velvet Revolution" in Iran, while I see nothing but Red Blood.
Velvet, Silk or Satin, or maybe just Black polyester, it doesn't really matter what you call it - the fact remains that thousands of Iranians have had it with the rule of the Ayatollahs.
You may argue that they after all just reformists, following orders from "milder" Ayatollahs like the corrupt Rafsandjani and the warmonger advisor to Khomeini- Musavi. And you may also argue that they are also seeking legitimacy by turning to less belligerent Ayatollahs for guidance. And you are right in arguing this.
However, I maintain that the majority of the Iranians who have not stopped protesting, risking their lives and those of their families, some being executed, some tortured, some disappeared, are NOT backers for the Reformist camp of Musavi and Co. I believe that within the very limited choice given - they opted to what they perceive to be the lesser evil - maybe not a door for radical change, but just a window of fresh air.
I therefore agree to a great extent with both the analyses of Hamid Dabashi (1) and the Iranian blogger Reza Fiyouzat (2) when addressing the current Iranian unrest/revolt and the Left's stand on this matter.
I also think that the Left in general is committing another huge mistake by not supporting the Iranian protests for change and reform. The idiotic conspiracy theories put forward by the leftists that the U.S, Saudi Arabia and even Israel are behind this unrest are ludicrous. This does not mean that the U.S would not add intensity to Iranian winds. However to argue that what is taking place in Iran is solely the work of American and British intelligence is stupid to say the least - as it willfully ignores the clear unceasing demands of the Iranian protesters.
As for seeing a Saudi role in these unrests is even stupider. Saudi Arabia has not even laid a finger in occupied Iraq, would it lay a finger in Iran ? Of course not. The Saudis are too busy holding on tight.
As for Israeli meddling - I doubt it too. Not because the Israelis are angels, but because the Iran of Khomeini and that of Khameini did more for Israel in the weakening of Iraq, its regime change and its ultimate destruction - more than what the Jewish state could have hoped for.
But of course your blind ideological left is oblivious to these truths - because they need to carry "the banner" at any cost, denying facts on the ground.
And a friend remarked lately -- IRNA, the official propaganda mouthpiece of the exclusive Shiite theocratic entity no longer needs to compose new propaganda pieces -it is instead relying on translations into Farsee of propaganda pieces from the leftist websites.
Having said that, I must also agree with Malcolm Lagauche who argues, that supporting the reformists may boil down to supporting in the end - Musavi and Rafsandjani - both advisors to Khomeini and I quote from Lagauche's article entitled Another Grand Illusion (3) dated July 6-9, 2009 -- "Former Prime Minister Mir Hossein Mousavi, who claims he is the rightful winner of the June 12 presidential election, was part of the group (along with his current allies former President Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani and former House Speaker Mehdi Karoubi) that favored secret contacts with the United States and Israel to get the military supplies needed to fight the war with Iraq. Khomeini’s blessing allowed Rafsanjani, Karoubi and later Mousavi to proceed with secret contacts that involved emissaries from the Reagan camp and the Israeli government."
So where does that leave us ?
It leaves me with my eyes wide open, it leaves me with supporting the protesters but remaining very aware of the fact that Musavi and Co. are not some ardent revolutionaries. They were and still are part and parcel of this lunatic exclusive Shiite Jaafari political rule - called the "Islamic" republic of Iran.
And I will also tell you, and this is shared by MANY Iraqis - the unrest in Iran is in the long run good for Iraq. Another truth, I will not hide from you.
After all, Iraq is under a DUAL American-Iranian occupations and add an Israeli one in the North. Another aspect that the cowardly, sold out left refuses to see and admit. So anything that helps us Iraqis get rid of any of those occupations is most welcomed.
In the short run, though, we will witness a resurgence of the sectarian Iraqi Shiite Alliance, of the puppet government. We will also witness, Iran like a wild bull kicking hard through the Kurds. We will also witness and I have mentioned that elsewhere that Iran will use its sectarian Shiite-Sunni card with more ardor - it has already done so in Yemen when only yesterday 8 Yemenis soldiers perished in clashes with the converted Yemenis to the Shiite Jaafari creed. We might witness too, the sectarian card being pushed big time in Eastern Saudi Arabia. The "leftists" Chomsky style are already talking of the "horrible oppression of Shiites" in " Wahabi" Saudi Arabia. -- just like they did when preparing the ideological atmosphere for the American occupation of Iraq, faithfully echoing the same arguments put forward by the Zionists in the White House, like Perle, Wolfowitz, Feith -- several articles and conferences are being waved and organized to that effect, regarding Saudi Arabia - using the "Sunni Wahabi" discourse just like they did when addressing "the Sunni Wahabi" regime of Saddam Hussein.
Like in a Corrida, the bull always kicks harder before it falls.
But let us carry no illusions on the possible fall. I personally exclude it, since the Pasdarans and their Basijis militias have already taken over the full control of the state apparatus under Khamenei's orders. And moreover a hardline Iran suits Jewish Zionist interests much better in the long run...
But let us assume for a moment that the hardline bull will fall, let us not lose sight and forget who the "reformist" leaders are - they are nothing but a lesser shade of Black.
My direct links are not working so am typing them here.
(1) Hamid Dabashi - Left is wrong on Iran -
http://www.uruknet.info/?p=m56133&hd=&size=1&l=e
(2) Reza Fiyouzat - Iran's absolutist Dictatorship reloaded -
http://www.uruknet.info/?p=m56335&hd=&size=1&l=e
(3) Malcolm Lagauche - Another Grand Illusion.
http://www.malcomlagauche.com/id12.html
|
|
:: Article nr. 56368 sent on 26-jul-2009 04:19 ECT
www.uruknet.info?p=56368
Link: arabwomanblues.blogspot.com/2009/07/velvet-revolution-or-lesser-shades-of.html
:: The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website.
|
COMMENTS BY READERS OF URUKNET
The COMMENTs of our readers are the sole responsability of their authors, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of URUKNET. If you believe that any COMMENT contains pornographic, racist or otherwise objectionable or offensive content, or if the COMMENT is contrary to law in any way, please let us know. Our legal representatives will review any and all complaints and, if any complaint is deemed to be accurate, the COMMENT will removed at once.
Comments must be pertinent to the article and must not exceed 5000 characters.
To publish long comments, send it to the our Editor, it can become an article.
Do not complain to the Editor if you do not agree with an article or with a comment: simply reply here below.
You can get the password to become a REGISTERED USER and POST YOUR COMMENTS by clicking HERE (needed only once forever).
Click HERE to post your own comment. Now, also users not registered can post their comments.
| Comment by steve in vista - 26 Jul 2009 - 04:34 [REGISTERED USER] | Dear Layla,
I remember the Iranian poster presence was strong in 2006 on the old WashingtonP ost.com board, no longer extant. They were in particular interested in, and we s poke of it, the students and the women’s right’s advocates bringing much needed change to Iran. These were young men who thought this way. There is always hope. We will see. I am being guarded, but never will I deny hope, for all of the region and the whole world.
Thoughtful and incisive as always, thank you Layla.
|
| Comment by safiya - 26 Jul 2009 - 20:01 [REGISTERED USER] | Great article Layla.
Good comment Steve.
Keep hope always. |
| Comment by - 26 Jul 2009 - 21:56 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | | We have to remain hopeful. |
| Comment by steve in vista - 26 Jul 2009 - 22:11 [REGISTERED USER] | Salam al-Maseeh, Layla wa algmi,
The U.S. CIA with the help of some others put in the Shah and took him out and t hen put the Ayatollah. They have, with Israel, groomed Ahmed-i-Nejad and will co ntinue to support these picks of theirs. It is an upward road at best for the tr ue Iranian patriots.
But we hope! And will help any way we can.
Ma assalama
Steve |
| Comment by rhondas commentary - 26 Jul 2009 - 23:48 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | Salam all,
Steve, I saw something on one of the links.
Did you know that just presently, American Indian activists are "supporting Isra el against Iranian (Ahmadinejad) nuclear terrorists". That is about as realistic and sensible as Palestinians supporting Shin Bet in order to protect themselves from Americans.
As my Dad would say, Oi vey!
Ma assalaamah |
| Comment by johndoylesr - 27 Jul 2009 - 01:58 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | | Dear Layla,Hello,This is a beautiful piece on hypocritical Iran,it`s all Shi`ite mullah bullshit!Replace one President who loves and bows to the supreme leader ,for another with a green wristband who supports,bows,&loves the supreme leader, it`s hypocrisy !Regards, |
| Comment by johndoylesr - 27 Jul 2009 - 01:59 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | | Dear Layla,Hello,This is a beautiful piece on hypocritical Iran,it`s all Shi`ite mullah bullshit!Replace one President who loves and bows to the supreme leader ,for another with a green wristband who supports,bows,&loves the supreme leader, it`s hypocrisy !Regards, |
| Comment by rhondas commentary - 27 Jul 2009 - 02:13 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | Here are the articles they are juxtaposing. I put them up as an example of the n onsense.
http://palestinecry.blogspot.com/2009/07/tweedle-dee-and-tweedle-dum-two-zionist .html
What I see being put forth is the idea that the Khazar Jew invaders of Palestine are the rightful occupants of that land and they will be the protectors of all in the region. That is total BULLSHIT. American leftists are swallowing it whole . The American leftists and other leftists will be the big betrayers of the whol e region. They will go back to their Zionist Jew Socialist roots and betray all of the Arab people. They will back up the Israelis in the face of this arranged farce of Iran supposedly opposing Israel. Iran is actually the Persian 'yah boss' Rochester to the Israelis.
Meanwhile I have noticed on far right supposedly "anti-Zionist" sites that Iran is the one portrayed as the good guy. So the Zionist shill far right supports Ir an and the Zionist shill left supports Israel. Both are damned liars. Both are r acists. Both are Zionists.
Meanwhile innocent Arabs and Pashtuns and others of Palestine and Iraq and Syria and Lebanon and Afghanistan and Pakistan are made to seem like this totally inv ented "Islamic Terror". That is TOTAL GODDAMED BULLSHIT LIES.
All of it is a carefully orchestrated way to try to mask the real reason for the Nakba (originally supported by Communist Russia) and the evil American genocida l invasion occupation of the region.
That real reason is bloodthirsty genocidal NWO Zionist dominion in the region. P eriod. |
| Comment by rhonda\'s commentary - 27 Jul 2009 - 02:17 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | My last Comment: Comment by rhondas commentary - 27 Jul 2009 - 02:13 [USER NOT R EGISTERED]
was in reference to my comment:
Comment by rhondas commentary - 26 Jul 2009 - 23:48 [USER NOT REGISTERED]
When I started writing it there were no comments posted in between. |
| Comment by rhonda\'s commentary - 27 Jul 2009 - 02:23 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | This is the link again to my post showing the lies I spoke of.
http://palestinecry.blogspot.com/2009/07/tweedle-dee-and-tweedle-dum-two-zionist .html
I you have problems with this link then copy and paste it and make sure there ar e no spaces put in by the software that copies it to the comment section.
The article is on Palestine Cry at
Monday, July 27, 2009
Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum, Two Zionist Peas in a Pod |
| Comment by safiya - 27 Jul 2009 - 02:30 [REGISTERED USER] | | Ronnie, good points and good article. I noticed also. |
| Comment by arjalea - 27 Jul 2009 - 03:49 [REGISTERED USER] | Salam Layla and everyone,
I agree Ronnie, the left and right are just very bad excuses and no help at all and as you say a cover up.
I think real women’s rights are a key here. Not western feminist. But real right s for women and their children.
I mean totally within the right to life. Without that, how can you say you are f or rights for Palestinians or Iraqis or any one?
We have to defend all.
Ma assalaamah
|
| Comment by safiya - 27 Jul 2009 - 09:15 [REGISTERED USER] | Iran
http://palestinecry.blogspot.com/2009/07/palestine-cry-overthrow-of-middle-east. html
http://cultureandlove.blogspot.com/2009/07/leila-hussein-holy-crimes-and-cia_451 8.html
http://cultureandlove.blogspot.com/2009/07/leila-hussein-holy-crimes-and-cia_26. html
http://cultureandlove.blogspot.com/2009/07/leila-hussein-holy-crimes-and-cia.htm l
|
| Comment by peterkhanzendran - 27 Jul 2009 - 18:52 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | | Those are NOT cospiracy theories about amrikan/zionist meddling in Iran, those a re FACT. Those riots/demos occured days after dick holbrooke's visit to the reg ion and during zionist military manouvers, so take your conspiracy terms dismiss ing this fact and shove it up your ass. |
| Comment by ardeshir - 29 Jul 2009 - 00:23 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | Dear Layla, (and others of similar opinion)
Please leave your anti-shiat bias at the door when entering the debate on Iran.
This has nothing to do with Shiat-Sunni divide. The people on the street are ask ing for their human rights to be respected. for their legal and constitutional r ights.
We the people of Iran do not want an Islamic government. We want an Iranian gove rnment, period.
I agree with the rest of your article, good work otherwise. |
| Comment by ardeshir - 29 Jul 2009 - 00:58 [USER NOT REGISTERED] | Dear Layla, (and others of similar opinion)
Please leave your anti-shiat bias at the door when entering the debate on Iran.
This has nothing to do with Shiat-Sunni divide. The people on the street are ask ing for their human rights to be respected. for their legal and constitutional r ights.
We the people of Iran do not want an Islamic government. We want an Iranian gove rnment, period.
I agree with the rest of your article, good work otherwise. |
|
[ Printable version
] | [ Send it to a friend ]
[ Contatto/Contact ] | [ Home Page ] | [Tutte le notizie/All news ]
|
|
Uruknet on Twitter
::
RSS updated to 2.0
:: English
:: Italiano
::
Uruknet for your mobile phone:
www.uruknet.mobi
The newsletter archive
|
:: If you find this site informative, please donate -
every donation helps us keep up with costs. Thanks.
|
:: All events
|