GI SPECIAL 3B98:
WELCOME TO YOUR PRIVATE CORNER IN HELL:
AMERICANS WANT YOU HOME:
BUSH WANTS YOU THERE:
WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON?
US Marines at
Tharthar Lake, Iraq. (AFP/USMC/File/Cpl. Robert R. Attebury)
Then There Are The Bad Days
Dust Storms, Sun Take Toll On Soldiers
July 22, 2005 By Capt. H.R. Grimm, Columnist, Chillicothe
Gazette
The intensity of dust storms have grounded flights and
convoys for days with visibility of less than a quarter mile.
No mail arrives, no evacuations take place and no convoys
move as the heat grinds the dust into every nook and cranny.
Soldiers who are housed in tents fight with poles and straps
that are loosened by the constant wind. Soldiers who are housed or work in
buildings re-caulk and re-tape every window and door against dust, sand, camel
spider, scorpion or other unwanted visitors.
The ground seems to move under one's feet as the shifting
sands fill the slightest corner or depression into snow like drifts.
It is an eerie sci-fi scene with Soldiers meandering around
with scarved and goggled faces bracing against the wind, heat and dust.
Life is ground to a slowness so that even the locals know
better than to venture out into the day.
Then there are the bad days. Days when it is only the
sunshine with its unrelenting heat bearing down promising to suck the very life
out of anyone who has failed to hydrate themselves.
These are the days when convoys are driving down the
highways and patrols are out looking for bomb making locations and attempting
to gain against the insurgents' planting of IEDs.
The local population is going to market and, amid this
sea of humanity, insurgents are able to blend into the fray firing off mortars,
attacking with VBIED and milling into crowds of civilians as suicide bombers.
All of this makes the reality of casualties a more likely
possibility.
My civilian friends, don't complain about the rain or
humidity or the temperature or the traffic or even the long line at your local
store.
Trust me, what is considered a bad day in the states is
better than a Soldier's good day here.
IRAQ WAR REPORTS
SAILOR DIES FROM BOMB BLAST WOUNDS
July 22, 2005 HEADQUARTERS UNITED STATES CENTRAL COMMAND
NEWS RELEASE Number: 05-07-14C
CAMP FALLUJAH, Iraq A Sailor assigned to Regimental
Combat Team-2, 2nd Marine Division, II Marine Expeditionary Force (Forward),
died July 21 of wounds received July 15 from an improvised explosive device.
The incident occurred during combat operations in Hit,
Iraq.
MARINE KILLED BY IED NEAR ZAIDON
July 22, 2005 HEADQUARTERS UNITED STATES CENTRAL COMMAND
NEWS RELEASE Number: 05-07-15C
CAMP FALLUJAH, Iraq A Marine assigned to Regimental
Combat Team-8, 2nd Marine Division, II Marine Expeditionary Force (Forward),
was killed in action July 21 by an improvised explosive device while conducting
combat operations near Zaidon, Iraq.
Fighting In Samarra
July 22, 2005 The Canadian Press
U.S. and Iraqi troops also clashed with militants in the
central Iraqi city of Samarra, leaving four dead, police said.
One Iraqi soldier, along with three civilians, were killed,
said police Capt. Laith Mohammed. Another 11 people were wounded, he said.
AFGHANISTAN WAR REPORTS
Karzai Sets Goal:
To Control Afghanistan
[Thanks to PB who sent this in. He writes: Great goal
for a country's ruler: control the country.]
Jul 22 AP: Afghan President Hamid Karzai said Friday that
his government was determined to gain control over the whole country but would
still require years of international support as Afghanistan emerges from
decades of civil war.
TROOP NEWS
Rape A House For George!
U.S. Command Wants Even More Dead And Maimed U.S.
Troops:
Stupid Terror Tactics Encouraging Thousands Of New
Recruits To Take Up Arms And Fight U.S. Soldiers
U.S. soldiers from the 256th Brigade Combat Team, 3rd
Infantry Division, break down the front door during a cordon and search mission
in Baghdad, in this military handout file photo taken July 14, 2005.
REUTERS/USAF/Staff Sgt. Jorge A. Photo by Reuters (Handout)
NEED SOME TRUTH? CHECK OUT TRAVELING SOLDIER
Telling the truth - about
the occupation or the criminals running the government in Washington - is the
first reason for Traveling Soldier. But we want to do more than tell the
truth; we want to report on the resistance - whether it's in the streets of
Baghdad, New York, or inside the armed forces. Our goal is for Traveling
Soldier to become the thread that ties working-class people inside the armed
services together. We want this newsletter to be a weapon to help you organize
resistance within the armed forces. If you like what you've read, we hope that
you'll join with us in building a network of active duty organizers. http://www.traveling-soldier.org/ And join with Iraq War vets in the call to
end the occupation and bring our troops home now! (www.ivaw.net)
Assholes In Metrics-land
Assistant Secretary of
Defense for International Security Affairs Peter Rodman, left, accompanied by
Lt. Gen. Walter Sharp, director of strategic policy and plans for the Joint
Chiefs of Staff, meets reporters at the Pentagon July 21 to discuss a Pentagon
report on Iraq. (AP Photo/Heesoon Yim)
Report to Congress Measuring Stability and Security in
Iraq
July 21, 2005 U.S. Department of Defense News Transcript
Peter Rodman, Assistant Secretary of Defense for
International Security Affairs:
We call this the Iraq Metrics Report.
Metrics is something we do ourselves. As you know,
Secretary Rumsfeld is passionate about metrics. It's a management tool.
Long before Congress asked us for this report, we have been doing our best to
apply rigorous standards of performance, particularly in the training, the
field of training Iraqi forces.
And I think this is a key dimension to watch, and the
metrics are, of course, the timeline, the schedule of political developments
that we're looking for the rest of this year. [Huh?]
MORE:
Pentagon Throws A Silly Air Ball
[Thanks to Don Bacon, who sent this in. He writes THE
PENTAGON DOESN'T HAVE A CLUE ABOUT WHEN WE CAN LEAVE IRAQ]
July 22, 2005 WASHINGTON (AP)
A Pentagon report [Report to Congress Measuring Stability
and Security in Iraq] offered no estimate of when U.S. troops could be
withdrawn. There are about 138,000 U.S. troops in Iraq.
But the Defense Department report did not say when Iraqi
security forces will be sufficiently trained to defend the country without
direct assistance from U.S. troops.
The 23-page report - the most comprehensive public
assessment yet by the military of progress in Iraq - was more than a week
overdue. In it, the Pentagon cites progress on political, economic and
security fronts.
U.S. officers have developed a method of calculating the
combat readiness of the 76,700 Iraqi Army troops, but the Pentagon said it
"should not and must not" publicly disclose specific data.
"The enemy's knowledge of such details would put both
Iraqi and coalition forces at increased risk," the report said. [The
resistance has perfect knowledge of such details, having infiltrated the
Occupation local intelligence, security, and armed forces from top to bottom.
Its only the whining, ass-kissing Imperial Senators who remain in ignorance:
they let the assholes from the Pentagon get away with this silly security
bullshit without demanding real answers right now.]
MORE ON METRICS:
Inflating Body Counts, And Transforming All The Dead
Into Enemy
By Stan Goff, http://stangoff.com [Excerpt]
Those of us who spent time humpin the boonies in Vietnam
remember this practice very well. Inflating body counts, and transforming all
the dead into enemy or suspected enemy.
Anyone with an ounce of critical capacity and a gram of
skepticism has figured this out about Iraq for a while now.
For those unschooled and inexperienced in war, and who
have been exposed to a lifetime of television and film where bad guys always
have poor marksmanship and good guys are Buffalo-fucking-Bill sharpshooters,
where no one is ever stumbling under 50 pounds of LCE, tripping over rubble,
falling into ditches, wheezing to catch their breath, firing suppressive fire
around corners or over the lip of erosion ditches with no regard for
bystanders, or returning fire in a general direction when they havent
identified where shots came from (usually people fire wherever the first person
who guesses out loud where the shots came from), and shooting each other in the
confusion people who have no experience of this plain, dumb, human confusion
and fallibility in combat, they can be fooled by their own internalized images
from those films where soldiers and cops are all highly-skilled, competent,
athletic, impervious to pain, and even well-read.
Aint so.
But the other reality of war, and the one I am highlighting
here .is that bystanders always get beat up in urban combat actions worse
than anyone, and are often attacked without provocation because of the
trigger-happy paranoia and rage of the troops who are dropped into their cities
troops who are not unlike hornets screwed inside a Mason jar.
What I am saying is that it is simply not possible that
when 50 people are killed in one of these actions, that all 50 are
insurgents.
Thats an outrageous claim on par with telling people
that a piss-ant just ate a bale of hay and the outrage is magnified by the
fact that the press repeats these figures WITH THE UNQUESTIONED CLAIM that the
dead (no wounded, mind you) were all insurgents.
IRAQ RESISTANCE ROUNDUP
Assorted Resistance Action
July 22, IRNA & By Frank Griffiths, Associated Press
According to a Baghdad police spokesman, a number of
armed men opened fire at a police patrol unit on duty in Baghdad's western
Baladiyyat District on Friday morning.
Two police officers got killed in the attack, one of whom
was high ranking, and another officer was critically wounded.
Half an hour later the insurgents launched another attack
in the same district, in which another police officer lost their lives.
In another ambush against a highway patrol in central
Baghdad two plain-clothes police commandos were killed on Friday.
A morning police patrol came under fire in the eastern Ghadeer
neighbourhood, leaving two officers dead and another injured, police officials
said. The injured officer was taken to Kindi Hospital, said police 1st Lt.
Ali Abbas.
Assailants shot dead three policemen in the eastern
Mashtal district in Baghdad as they were directing traffic, said police Lt.
Osama Adnan.
In the same area, clashes erupted at dawn between
insurgents and a joint Iraqi police-army patrol, leaving two suspected
insurgents dead, police said.
Three other suspected insurgents were arrested, police
said. A soldier and a police officer were wounded in the fighting, said Capt.
Jassim Al-Wahash.
Masked guerrillas wounded Yahya al-Haidari, a local chief
of the Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq, as he drove in
Mosul, hospital officials said.
Iraq's interior minister announced here Friday morning that
the dead corpses of three Iraqi brothers who were shot in their heads and
chests on Thursday, were found by police forces in north of Baghdad on Friday.
Two of the assassinated brothers were police officers,
while the third was a congregational prayer imam at a Baghdad district's
mosque.
NO OIL FOR BLOOD
Damaged oil pipeline engulfed in flames July 21, 2005, in
northern Beiji in the Makhool district 143 miles north of Baghdad. Wednesday
night insurgents attacked an oil pipeline with explosives causing a massive
explosion and fire. (AP Photo/Bassim Daham)
FORWARD OBSERVATIONS
Where The Arab And Muslim Community Will Stand On
September 24
Under the pretext of
reaching out to a wider population, it is we, the targeted communities, who are
being squeezed out and shunned aside by those calling for a separate march.
And under the guise of minimalist slogans, it is the political demands of those
at the receiving end of war that are being muted and silenced.
7.22.05 Statement
On September 24 in Washington, DC the Arab American and
the Muslim community will stand united with all targeted communities against
the onslaught of the National Security State at home and abroad, as we declare
a clear opposition to the war on Iraq.
We will assemble from far and wide in a unified mobilization
at the White House under the banner of the September 24 National Coalition for
the March on Washington with thousands of people from every community, region,
sector and background to send a message to the Bush administration that its
illegal war and occupation must come to an end. In addition to Washington, DC,
we will also simultaneously mobilize in Los Angeles and San Francisco to send a
powerful national message on a massive scale.
Emphasizing the consensus of the movement worldwide that
war is neither singular in nature nor narrow in goals, we will inextricably
support the struggle of the Palestinian people for freedom and return.
As people in Palestine march the streets in support of their
Iraqi brothers and sisters and as the Palestinian flag is waved in Iraq, we
fully understand that those struggles cannot be disconnected from each other.
We are honored to insist on standing with our brothers
and sisters in Haiti as they face off ongoing assaults, for their struggle is
also ours. It should not be any other way. As such, we will stand in
solidarity with all those targeted by Empire as we collectively share the wrath
of its violence. We will defend civil rights and liberties, and reject any
attempt to falsely position Muslims and Arab Americans as outsiders in this
society.
Indeed, forty-two years ago, the 1963 March on Washington
carried the bitter struggle of generations as it announced that the violence
and hatred of racism and segregation have no place in our midst. That march
continues to this very day, as we in turn announce that war and occupation also
have no place in our midst.
As we march in the
footsteps of those who have preceded us in the streets of Washington, DC, and
despite repeated attempts by the leadership of United for Peace and Justice
(UFPJ) to create political segregation under various false pretexts, we will
not be shunned nor will we start from separate rallies or segregated points of
departure.
We are angered that UFPJ leadership would attempt to
divert activists headed for Washington, DC on that day away from where our
community will be standing.
Those days of separation, we believed, are over. We are
saddened that the leadership of the very organization to which we extended a
sincere invitation of partnership, UFPJ, would instead respond 11 days later by
calling for a rival and segregated protest on the same day and in the same
place, simply to spite our community, oust Haiti and Palestine from the slogans
of the anti-war movement, and remove Arabs and Muslims from positions of
leadership.
Under the pretext of
reaching out to a wider population, it is we, the targeted communities, who are
being squeezed out and shunned aside by those calling for a separate march.
And under the guise of minimalist slogans, it is the political demands of those
at the receiving end of war that are being muted and silenced.
In its behavior, the leadership of UFPJ is fanning the
flames of separation and is unnecessarily pitting trusting movement activists
against our community and people. Last year, hundreds of organizations and
thousands upon thousands of activists took a clear stand against the
marginalization of the Arab and Muslim community, and in favor of a principled
political position. Yet, here we are again, facing the same attempts of
separation by the same leadership of UFPJ.
It has become too common for some sectors in the US
anti-war movement to be selective about opposition to Empire for their own
political gains and demand that various targeted communities must wait.
But todays war on and occupation of Iraq, against which
we all stand from the first day of sanctions until now, is a manifestation of
an ongoing larger quest for dominance targeting all.
Consider the Palestinian peoples perspective - what more
can they wait for?
Their land has been
colonized through a racist Zionist political program; the vast majority of the
Palestinian people has been expelled and remains in exile for nearly six
decades; more than 550 villages and towns have been erased and the destruction
continues; at least 650,000 have been jailed so far; massacres upon massacres
have been committed; and the killing of Palestinian Arabs has been normalized.
All with full US backing and total cover, as an integral component of that same
overall strategy of Empire.
And all while the same
sectors of the movement still say, wait. What else must we wait for?
Because we are at the primary receiving end of war, and
in spite of its systematic violence and persecution here and abroad, we will
neither wait, be sidelined, tokenized or be spoken for. We will not re-live
the past. As we in the US join a galvanized world against the occupation of
Iraq, our inextricable demands for justice must be put forward.
And as we march on to realize a dream long deferred, we
are reminded of what Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. wrote in his Letter from
Birmingham Jail: For years now I have heard the word Wait!This Wait has
almost always meant Never. We must come to seethat justice too long
delayed is justice deniedPerhaps it is easy for those who have never felt the
stinging dark of segregation to say, Wait.
The streets of Washington, DC for decades have witnessed the
struggles for ending hegemony over our communities and against separation and
isolation. To us, purposely assembling apart and marching away from our young
and old can only have one meaning!!
What does the leadership of UFPJ gain by continuing to
pit activists and communities against each other? Unity with those facing
Empire should not just be an option; it should be a must!
We call on every community center and place of worship,
on every student group and grassroots organization to join the thousands who
will assemble at the White House on September 24.
We call on all to leave behind the era of separation and
to join in unity.
All Out on September 24!
Muslim American Society (MAS) Freedom Foundation
National Council of Arab Americans
Imam Johari Abdul-Malik, Chairman, Coordinating Council of
Muslim Organizations
Al-Awda: The Palestine Right to Return Coalition
Arab Muslim American Federation
The Palestine Right of Return Congress
Free Palestine Alliance
Palestinian American Women Association
Middle East Cultural and Information Center
This Is No Way To Build A Movement That Can Force The
U.S. Military Out Of Iraq
July 22, 2005 WHAT WE THINK, Socialist Worker [Excerpts]
A national antiwar mobilization has been called for
September 24 in Washington, D.C., the first in many months. This has the
potential to tap the growing opposition to the U.S. occupation of Iraq--despite
Bushs cynical attempt to use the July 7 London bombings to boost support for
the war on terror.
The biggest mobilization of the fall will be the national
antiwar protest called for September 24 by the antiwar groups United for Peace
and Justice (UFPJ) and ANSWER.
The antiwar movement has been at a standstill since 2004,
in large part because UFPJ leaders decided to devote their resources to getting
Bush out of office--which meant backing pro-war Democrat John Kerry.
Unfortunately, these same political weaknesses are reflected in the way that
UFPJ is organizing for this march.
A recent UFPJ action alert argued, If we organize in
an inclusive way, with broad demands, accessible language, and an inviting
style, we have the potential to organize the largest and most diverse
demonstration against the war to date, with people from all walks of life
coming together in a clear call to bring our troops home now.
But the point of the UFPJ alert is the opposite of being
inclusive--to try to justify why the march will not include any reference to
critical issues of the movement, such as Israels occupation of Palestine.
The messages authors, Leslie Cagan, George Friday, Judith
LeBlanc and George Martin ask that we go outside our comfort zones and speak
to people our movements dont typically reach.
Limiting the demands of the march, they argue, will
attract people from all walks of life--but their focus is really on the
Democrats in Congress.
Meanwhile, they are willing to shut out Arabs and
Muslims--who must play a central part in the antiwar movement--and relegate
important issues like justice for Palestine and the witch-hunt of Arabs and
Muslims to the back of the bus. This is no way to build a movement that can
force the U.S. military out of Iraq.
Its possible to transform the political climate in this
country and give voice to the millions of people who are fed up with George W.
Bush--but only if we confront the conservative agenda head-on.
This was the approach of the most vibrant antiwar activism
so far this year--the struggle to kick military recruiters off college and high
school campuses.
Now there are new opportunities to organize resistance on
other issues as well. Its time to take the initiative.
What do you think? Comments from service men and women, and veterans,
are especially welcome. Send to contact@militaryproject.org. Name, I.D.,
withheld on request. Replies confidential.
IRAQI TROOPS SEARCH HOMES IN COLUMBUS, OHIO
(REUTERS/HO/USMC/Lance
Cpl. Lucian Friel)
Above, Iraqi Occupation Army Sgt. Khurr'ub Hussein
searches a house during Operation Guardian Sword in the Ohio town of Columbus,
in this military handout photo released on July 20, 2029.
The Sgt. was conducting counter-insurgency operations
with the newly organized U.S. Transitional Forces loyal to the free, wholesome,
democratic U.S. provisional government headed by Benedict Arnold Capone.
Fifty-five terrorists belonging to the fundamentalist
Minute Men gang were killed during the three day operation, 26 wounded, and
1364 suspected terrorists taken prisoner. They have been using women and
children as human shields, a Capone press officer said, explaining why many
have died during the operation.
General Raschid Al-Hadr told reporters that the back of
the insurgency has been broken, and that the terrorists are in their last
throes. Its only the foreign fighters coming over the border from Canada
and Mexico that are keeping the insurgency going, he said.
Americans want the new freedoms we bring them, and they
are learning how to govern themselves. Their children are so happy when we
throw them candy and give them pencils.
Terrorists Captured Near Cincinnati
Men suspected of being American insurgents are handcuffed
during Operation al-Shrouq (Sunrise), a joint Iraqi and U.S. and military sweep
in southern Ohio province near the restive insurgent stronghold of Cincinnati,
in this military handout photo released July 17, 2029.
The man seen kneeling at left, wearing an American flag
t-shirt, was identified by Multilateral Forces intelligence officers as Wilber
Isom, Commander of the Tom Paine underground terrorist cell, made up of foreign
fighters and freedom-hating fanatical Methodist fundamentalist terrorists, who
kill and eat small babies.
In other news, gunmen kidnapped Australias envoy to
Washington on July 21, the latest in a series of attacks that have driven
diplomats from the U.S. capital and hurt the Iraqi-backed government's bid for
recognition from its neighbors. Police sources said gunmen in two cars
snatched the Australian mission chief off the street outside a Georgetown
restaurant along with a diplomatic attach. (Reuters - Handout)
A History Of U.S. Armed Forces Rebellions:
Vietnam:
Individual Refusals Spread To Involve Entire
Companies
[Continued]
They also declared their
own ceasefire, refusing to fight unless fired upon.
These men saw the
necessity of building peace from below and solidarity with each other. As
one soldier explained, Theyre trying to separate us, trying to keep it from
being unified. They know if were unified they cant do anything. They cant
court-martial the whole company.
By Martin Smith (Sgt. USMC; out of service)
Writing this was about healing a really dark chapter in
my life, my experience in the marine corps. The words I wrote came out of an
inner pain and experience that needed to heal.
But most of all, I hope that my words in some way bring
an end to this god damn war and that no one else will have to come back in a
body bag.
This isn't about me, it's all about bringing the troops
home now,
Martin Smith
Analyzing soldiers poetry can further substantiate the
contradictory expressions of the grunts world.
In addition to the combat gear that included ammo pouches,
canteens, a first-aid kit, flak jacket, hand grenades, and mosquito repellent,
many soldiers also carried a Zippo lighter. These lighters were coveted for
their consistent flame in lighting cigarettes and also for use in burning down
village huts of suspected revolutionary insurgents, called zippoing a hooch
by soldiers. Inscribed on these lighters, often traded on the black market or
exchanged for the services of a prostitute, are contradictory markings that
reflect the anger, revenge, sadness, and the emerging anti-military and
anti-war consciousness of the soldiers.
In Jim Fiorellas The Viet Nam Zippo, pictures of these
highly prized collector items that date roughly from the 1960s to 1972 show a
broad range of messages.
Some lighter engravings express a celebration and
self-identity with the brutality of war, Death is my Business and Business Has
Been Good; Yea Though I Walk Through the Valley of the Shadow of Death I Fear
No Evil For Im the Evilest Son of a Bitch in the Valley; Let Me Win Your
Heart and Mind or Ill Burn Your Hut Down; for example.
Others include carvings of unit numbers and some contain
pictures of naked women, revealing the particular gendered response of male
troops.
Some lighters, however, reveal a more critical view of
combat experience and provide an example of informal resistance, providing troops
with a simple outlet to criticize their military service. These Zippos
include: It Seems the Days in the Army are the Longest Days on the Earth; If
I had a farm In vietnam and A home in hell Id sell my farm And go home; When
I Die Ill Go to Heaven Because Ive Spent My Time In Hell; and The Army is a
Rubber It Gives You the Feeling of Security While You are Getting Fucked, this
last example, provides more evidence of the male-centered world of the combat
soldier.
In addition, many lighters move beyond describing the
braggadocio of killing and the hell of war, revealing an oppositional culture
that developed amongst the troops.
Peace signs and FTA, for Fuck the Army, engravings
were some of the numerous anti-military inscriptions that also included: Ours
is Not To Do or Die Ours is to Smoke and Stay High; If I Die in Vietnam Bury
Me on My Stomach so the Army Can Kiss My Ass; and We Are the Unwilling Led by
the Unqualified Doing the Unnecessary for the Ungrateful, also known as UUUU.
Similar slogans were also chalked on helmets. These
etchings express a hidden area of soldiers protest, hidden from the major
media and pentagon press releases, which swelled amongst the troops during the
final years of the war.
In 1968, revolutionary forces launched the Tet Offensive, a
coordinated attack on more than a hundred cities in South Vietnam during the
Vietnamese Lunar New Year holiday.
The attack surprised the U.S. and South Vietnamese military
and revealed widespread civilian support for the North Vietnamese. For the
first time, revolutionary forces, taking great loss in human life, invaded the
cities in South Vietnam. Tet was a watershed and a decisive turning point in
the war. A potential major victory turned into a disastrous defeat through
mistaken estimates, loss of nerve, and a tidal wave of defeatism, as military
historian Brigadier General S. L. A. Marshall put it. Previously, President
Johnson promised that victory was around the corner. Tet exposed the lies of
the military planners and government officials. The war would no longer be the
same.
After Tet, the contradictions produced by the war turned
a significant minority of troops towards open rebellion.
In 1968 alone, there were sixty-eight incidents of
combat refusals in Vietnam, an official euphemism for disobedience to
orders.
In a 1970 article in the New York Times, Fred Gardner
described how troops took part in search and evade missions in which they
disobeyed orders and went out to a safe perimeter location and called in wrong
locations, pretending to carry out their assigned missions. We smoke, rap
and sack out, according to one Vietnam veteran in the article.
Gardner claimed that thousands of U.S. soldiers used this
tactic in Vietnam, and his assertion is substantiated by a similar episode in
the CBS news documentary, The World of Charlie Company, recorded in 1970.
On film intended for U.S. audiences, 1st and 2nd squads
blatantly radio in false positions to their superior officer, Captain Rice.
Ordered to separate out by one kilometer, the two squads refuse the order with
confidence. The soldiers reason that if they came in contact with the enemy,
they would be safer in one team that includes both squads of all twenty members,
rather than in two dispersed teams.
The soldiers disobedience reveals the changing
consciousness that emerged during the war, but it also exposes how their
actions were firmly rooted in the experience of the grunt as a collective
laborer, looking out for each others survival.
Soldiers began to question the military doctrine of
obedience to all orders, as they came to realize that their own lives and that
of their buddies should come first.
According to Fred Gardners New York Times article in 1970,
individual refusals to fight became so widespread at the army base camp at Cu
Chi, located 25 miles of Saigon, the military set up a unique company for such
men. A soldier stationed at Cu Chi explained:
They have set up separate companies for men who have
refused to go out to the field. It is no big thing here anymore to refuse to
go. If a man is ordered to go such and such place he no longer goes through
the hassle of refusing; he just packs his shirt and goes visit some buddies at
another base campMany guys dont even put on their uniforms anymore. I am
almost always wearing a pair of keds, a blue tie-dye shirt and army pants I
made into cut-offs. I put in an appearance at work sometimes to see if Ive
gotten any mail.
The above revelation about Cu Chi paints a markedly
different portrait of the life of a soldier in Vietnam. The lack of punitive
action, that it is no big thingto refuse to go, suggests these individual
refusals were widespread, involving numerous troops who gained a sense of
independence and subverted the team of warriors into a group of non-compliers.
The Army convicted soldiers of 330 incidents of
insubordination, mutiny, or other acts involving willful refusal to perform a
lawful order between 1968-1970 and numerous other incidents occurred that were
not prosecuted under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). No longer
killing machines, these troops instead wanted to save their own lives and
return to the world.
By 1969, these individual refusals spread to involve
entire companies.
Individual refusals mushroomed to involve more troops due
again to the collective nature of the basic fighting unit, the squad.
When one team of a platoon refused an order, it would
affect the whole company. Other teams would have to either cover and work in
the place of the rebellious team or join in the mutiny as well.
It became a simple matter of--whose side are you on?
According to David Cortright, ten major mutinies occurred in
the later years of the war.
On August 24, 1969, for example, 60 men of Alpha Company
of the 3rd Battalion/196th Infantry refused to move down the dangerous terrain
of the Nuilon Mountain. The incident received press coverage, and none of the
men received disciplinary action. Similarly, CBS news filmed the mutiny of
Charlie Company, 1st Air Calvary Division. On April 6, 1970 the entire company
refused to walk down what they perceived as a dangerous trail, possibly booby
trapped or filled with enemy personnel. Second squad initiated the mutiny, and
it spread to the entire company. Yet the military did not punish any of the
soldiers.
As Gordy Lee, one of the
leaders of the mutiny explained in an interview broadcast on national
television, The CO says were gonna walk the road, and the whole company says,
No, Negative! We heard of too many companiesgonna walk the road and thats
why they arent what they are now. They just got blown away. Both of these
incidents reveal the changed consciousness that took place in Vietnam born out
of the collective solidarity of soldiers who were watching each others back
against a new enemythe military itself.
Richard Boyle, a freelance journalist, reported an
eyewitness account of a mutiny in Flower of the Dragon.
On October 10, 1971, after the third platoon of the First
Cavalry Division at Firebase Pace refused to go out on what they considered a
suicide mission, the Brass threatened six GIs with a court martial.
In response, about 30 members of the other platoons held
a meeting and voted to stand in solidarity with the accused.
They composed a petition signed by 63 members of the company
to Senator Ted Kennedy requesting his help and protection from suicide
missions.
They also declared their own ceasefire, refusing to fight
unless fired upon.
These men saw the necessity of building peace from
below and solidarity with each other. As one soldier explained, Theyre
trying to separate us, trying to keep it from being unified. They know if
were unified they cant do anything. They cant court-martial the whole
company.
This example at Firebase Pace also shows how a horizontal
leadership developed within these mutinies that challenged the military system
of rank and obedience to orders.
These troops voted on their decisions and declared their
own peace missions instead of their assigned search and destroy mission.
The scope and breadth of the soldiers rebellion reached
what David Cortright described as a virtual general strike amongst a sizable
minority of enlisted people.
Troops went to Vietnam to find, fix and finish the enemy,
engaging in back-breaking labor through thick forests of tropical thorns and
bush. They emerged from the fields, however, forever changed.
For many, the thrill of killing and the psychological lift
of war brought out the brutal side that humanity is capable of.
For others, a questioning and emerging contradictory
experience led them to acts of refusal.
The very troops who committed war atrocities on one day,
might on another, take part in the soldiers rebellion.
Individual combat refusals mushroomed to include the
unity of entire companies based on a horizontal leadership.
Yet after remaining in the field for up to thirty or more
days, all troops would return to base camp and life in the rear to resupply,
take liberty, and have a chance to recoup. For many, life in the rear brought
its own unique conditions that fomented a different kind of rebellion.
[To be continued.]
OCCUPATION REPORT
Remembering Fallujah 2003:
Fury As US Soldiers Shoot Two Protesters Dead
U.S. military policeman takes
an Iraqi man detained into a Humvee at the city of Fallujah June 6, 2003. (AP
Photo/Victor R. Caivano)
Many people believe
these are occupying forces. And many of them are still cautious until they see
their intentions, Taha Bedaiwi al-Alwani said.
5.1.03 BY CATHERINE PHILP, London Times Online
FALLUJAH: More than 1,000 demonstrators were marching
yesterday on the former Baath party headquarters in the town, where American
troops had taken up their positions, when an armoured patrol tried to force its
way past.
Demonstrators say that a brick was thrown at one of the
vehicles; American military officials insist that bullets were fired from the
crowd.
Whichever was true, jittery forces immediately opened
fire on the protesters from their vehicles and from inside the compound, killing
two and wounding 12.
The crowd scattered and the wounded were rushed to hospital,
but within an hour the protesters had regrouped again outside the compound,
baying [Dogs bay. OK, so the reporter is a racist piece of shit. You can
still read between the lines.] for the Americans to withdraw as the troops
sat behind coils of razor wire, nervously eyeing the crowd.
There is no God but Allah! the protesters chanted, sitting
in the street, as a fresh convoy of American troops rumbled along the street
towards them.
As the tanks approached, the protesters surged forward,
screaming at the soldiers and hurling their shoes at the tanks, a grave insult
in Islamic culture.
With our souls and our blood we sacrifice Islam, they
chanted, carrying a local mullah on their shoulders towards the column of
tanks.
The tanks screeched to a halt and quickly reversed,
crushing a traffic reservation in their haste to reroute. Then the crowd
turned their anger on the soldiers stationed inside the compound, shouting:
You are killers. Go, go home!
American military officials blamed infiltrators for the
incident, but acknowledged that they may have killed innocent civilians
while responding to what they insisted was enemy fire.
The evil-doers are deliberately placing at risk the good
civilians, Lieutenant-Colonel Tobin Green, of the 3rd Armoured Cavalry
Regiment, said. These are deliberate actions by the enemy to use the
population as cover. [Hard to believe that idiotic crap like this was
once taken seriously.]
Residents insist that there were no security problems in
Fallujah before the arrival of the Americans and that there is no cause for
them to stay.
The fighting will go on day by day here until the
Americans leave, one protester said, shaking his fist at the gate of the
American compound.
Military officials confirmed that about 100 soldiers
involved in the first shooting had vacated the primary school compound and had
left the city, but they said that no more troops would be withdrawn.
The mayor of Fallujah, a former Iraqi exile appointed
after the fall of the old regime, said that he had told the Americans not to
provoke people by occupying sensitive areas such as mosques and schools for
fear of further violence.
Many people believe these are occupying forces. And
many of them are still cautious until they see their intentions, Taha Bedaiwi
al-Alwani said.
U.S. Military Police arrest Iraqi men from the city of
Fallujah, June 6, 2003. (AP Photo/Victor R. Caivano)
Remembering Fallujah 2003:
"They Came To Liberate Us?"
"What Is The Point Of Doing This?"
In one classroom, "I
(love) pork," with the word love represented by a heart, was written on
the blackboard, along with a drawing of a camel and the words: "Iraqi Cab
Company." In another room, "Eat (expletive) Iraq" was scrawled
on a wall. And in Ahmed's office, sexual organs were drawn with white chalk on
the back of the door.
May 2, 2003 By Rajiv Chandrasekaran and Scott Wilson,
Washington Post
FALLUJAH: At the school where Monday's shooting occurred,
teachers spent the day cleaning up in preparation for the start of classes on
Saturday. The headmaster, Mohammed Ahmed, said that before they left, U.S.
soldiers had damaged furniture and classroom supplies and left offensive
graffiti on the walls.
In one classroom, "I (love) pork," with the
word love represented by a heart, was written on the blackboard, along with a
drawing of a camel and the words: "Iraqi Cab Company." In another
room, "Eat (expletive) Iraq" was scrawled on a wall. And in Ahmed's
office, sexual organs were drawn with white chalk on the back of the door.
"They came to liberate us?" Ahmed asked,
pointing out the graffiti to a reporter.